“A snowy, flocked Christmas tree brought instant winter wonderland vibes into ’70s homes,” Bartlett says. “They make the perfect backdrop for colorful lights and playful ornaments.

Christmas in the 70s, 80s, and 90s hit differently—those were the days of tinsel-covered trees, bulky camcorders, and unbridled joy over toys that now feel iconic.

Hobby Lobby has been making its presence known around the Jersey Shore, opening a store in Neptune, as well as announcing ...