The shells are also on the small side, although they had a nice bite and held plenty of cheese sauce in each. Overall, the Cabot mac and cheese that we sampled was good but nothing to write home ...

And, as you might expect, that title can change based on the type of cheese—and who’s voting. In 2024, you might recall Cabot Creamery brought home the gold for its Extra Sharp Cheddar, Monterey Jack, ...