The key to a sultry yet subtle makeup look? Brown eyeliner — a trend that's just been embraced by Hailey Bieber.

Dark brown may be a better color choice than black for a softer, lighter look that doesn’t weigh down the eyes, especially for day-to-day wear. Brown smudged eyeliner looks provide a natural ...

While it's perfectly fine to use dark liner on the top lids, if you have older eyes, try using a lighter shade on the bottom.

Why We Love It: Clinique is always a safe bet for those with sensitive eyes. Its gel eyeliner—and a water-resistant and fragrance-free—provides pigment-rich color for up to 12 hours of wear on your ...