As a real-life married couple playing a fictional couple, Dave Franco and Alison Brie have spent a considerable amount of time comparing and contrasting their relationship to that of their characters in the just-released horror movie Together.

During an exclusive interview with PEOPLE at the Los Angeles premiere of their new film Together, the couple, who married in 2017, revealed that their anniversary tradition involves a slightly "embarrassing" rewatch of their proposal. Only, there is a bit of a catch.